Statistics watchdog queries Miliband unemployment claims

26 February 2013

The Chair of the UK Statistics Authority Andrew Dilnot has today written to Labour Leader Ed Miliband over his claim in the Sun newspaper that in Europe "only crisis-hit Spain has higher numbers of young unemployed than the UK."

The claim isn't inaccurate - it is, according to Mr Dilnot, "consistent with the latest published data for total numbers of unemployed people" - but it doesn't necessarily tell the whole story.

This is because the Labour Leader has chosen to focus on the number of unemployed people in each country across Europe, rather than the proportion of each country's workforce. As Mr Dilnot says, the resulting comparison "may be heavily affected by the relative sizes of the general population."

Instead, the Statistics Authority recommends that we compare the unemployment rate of the various European nations. While this isn't perfect - there are some inconsistencies in measuring the economic activity rate, for example - it does offer us a picture that accounts for the different-sized workforces across the continent.

So how does this change the overall picture?

As we can see from the table below, it actually changes it significantly.

The UK is actually one of the better performing nations when unemployment is considered as a proportion of the economically active, even though it ranks second in Europe for youth unemployment in terms of the raw numbers out of work.

So while Mr Miliband's claim isn't wrong, it risks leaving the Sun's readers with a more gloomy picture than might be deserved.

Full Fact fights bad information

Bad information ruins lives. It promotes hate, damages people’s health, and hurts democracy. You deserve better.