A-levels: from grade inflation to reforms

Published: 15th Aug 2013

  • A-Levels comprise the Advanced Subsidary (AS) - a qualification in its own right - and the A2, which is not.
  • Pupils wishing to enter A-levels should achieve at least 5 GCSE with grades A*-C.
  • Critics have expressed concerns about grade inflation. They see the steady rise in average grades for nearly 20 consecutive years as evidence that A-levels are getting easier.
  • To address this as well as a series of other concerns, Education Secretary Michael Gove announced plans to reform the A-levels structure and the teaching curriculum.

Evidence of grade inflation

In 1987 grade allocation quotas (where 10% of candidates would get an A, 15% a B, 10% a C, and so on) was abolished and replaced by "criteria referencing".

Since this point there has been a sharp increase in student performance, particularly at the upper end of the scale. In 1982 the A grade was awarded to only 8.9% of entrants. By 2012 26.6% of students were achieving A or A* grades.

(Source: Alan Smithers on A-levels, Centre for Education and Employment Research, University of Buckingham)

A-levels in the 21st century

In 2000 new reforms to A-levels introduced AS-levels, an intermediate qualification between GCSE and the full A-level, which it was hoped would encourage students to study a wider range of subjects.

A-level courses have also changed since 2000 with the number of 'units' making up a qualification being reduced from six to four. The amount of coursework required from students has also reduced.

In 2010, an additional A* grade was introduced with the aim of helping universities identify the very best performers. 

A-level reforms expected to be in place by September 2015

In 2010 the goverment published a White Paper on the future of A-levels. This was followed by a consultation run by Ofqual on the same subject. The changes being proposed include:

  • In future, universities will play a greater role in the development of A-levels.
  • Students will be limited in the number of resits they take.
  • The assessment system within A-levels will change, rendering the qualification fully linear. This means assessments will take place at the end of the course, rather than throughout the year.
  • AS qualifications will be "de-coupled" from A-levels; this means AS levels grade will not contribute to a full A-level qualification.

In a letter to Ofqual, Education Secretary Michael Gove said that he wanted the reform to be put into place by September 2015. That's when the new A-levels are expected to be taught in schools.

The four awarding organisations that offer A-levels in England (AQA, OCR, Pearson Edexcel and WJEC) have agreed to review the curriculum content in 13 subjects, including Maths, English, Biology and Computing.

Find out more on A-levels:

Michael Gove's letter to Ofqual

Ofqual's Impact Assessment of A-level reform

Ofqual's factsheet on A-level reform

Full Fact on grade inflation (2010)

Fit for Purpose? The view of the higher education sector, teachers and employers on the suitability of A levels (Ipsos Mori)

Full Fact: Are GCSEs better than AS-levels for predicting university success?

Was this page useful to you? Yes  No


Featured

Our pledge to you this election–and how you can help

We aim for our factchecks to be as accurate and up-to-date as possible. If you think we've made an error or missed some relevant information, please email team@fullfact.org.

Tweet

Share