Labour corrects broadband cost figure

25 November 2019
What was claimed

Full-fibre has low maintenance costs once rolled out, which can be estimated at around £230 million a year.

Our verdict

This is based on a miscalculation. Data from the infrastructure agency suggests costs would be two to four times this amount.

“Full-fibre has low maintenance costs once rolled out, which can be estimated at around £230 million a year.”

Labour party, 14 November 2019

When the Labour party, announced its new policy to nationalise Openreach and roll out full fibre broadband nationwide, it incorrectly said the cost of maintaining the network would be £230 million a year.

This was based on a misreading of analysis and Labour has since corrected the figure to estimate operating costs would be around £580 million per year.

What went wrong?

Labour based its figures on analysis by the National Infrastructure Commission which estimated that operating costs for a full fibre network over 30 years would be £6.9 billion. What Labour appeared to have done is divided that £6.9 billion by 30 to get an annual cost of £230 million.

The problem is that £6.9 billion doesn’t actually represent what anyone who isn’t familiar with corporate finance would recognise as £6.9 billion. The actual amount the government would have to spend is much higher, and that’s because of something called the present value of money.

Present value as a concept is based on the idea that an amount of money today is worth more than the same amount in the future.

For example, if you’re an investor you might be able to turn £1,000 you have today into £1,100 by next year by making a profit off your initial investment.     

So you would say the “present value” of £1,100 next year is £1,000 today.

That £6.9 billion was the estimated present value of maintaining a full fibre broadband network over thirty years. That means that, practically speaking, a much larger amount of cash will have to be spent on the maintenance.

Government spending is always talked about in terms of the required cash spend.

The apparent error was first uncovered by former fund manager Sam Taylor on Twitter who estimated that if you reverse engineered the figures to turn present value into cash value, that £6.9 billion triples. From that you can infer broadband maintenance costs of £690 million a year, rather than £230 million.

That said, you don’t even need to do this reverse engineering, because consultants hired by the National Infrastructure Commission have already estimated the cash cost of maintaining a fibre network.

They estimated a cost of between £579 million per year and £1.1 billion per year, depending on the type of rollout planned.

After being notified of the error, Labour corrected its figure to £579 million per year, the cost under a scenario of providing fibre broadband to all homes and workplaces.

Labour also said its spending plans included additional money “to err on the side of caution.”

Full Fact fights bad information

Bad information ruins lives. It promotes hate, damages people’s health, and hurts democracy. You deserve better.