On the face of it, today's GCSE results figures are alarming: the proportion of pupils getting five A*-C grades, including English and Maths, fell from 59.2% last year to 52.6% this year.
But comparing the year-on-year results doesn't in itself prove a dramatic fall in standards. As the Department for Education (DfE) is at pains to point out, the way GCSE results are measured has changed a great deal.
Firstly, resits are no longer included, so while pupils' final grades—including any retakes after initial poor results—were counted in 2012/13, now the figures just reflect a pupil's first attempt.
Also 3,000 largely vocational qualifications considered equivalent to GCSEs, have been removed from this year's figures to meet the DfE's new 'quality criteria'. Furthermore, no qualification can now count as more than a single GCSE, since previously some of these vocational qualifications could count for several at once.
A fairer comparison, as the DfE suggest, is to apply the new methodology to last year's results which finds that 56% of pupils achieved five A*-C grades, including English and Maths. So measured this way today's 52.6% is still a drop, if less dramatic. Crucially, we can't account for how schools might have changed their behaviour last year had the new performance measures come in then, so last year's figure may not represent 'what would have been'.
Can you help protect this election from the influence of bad information? Support Full Fact
This election, clear, accurate facts won’t always be a guarantee. False and harmful claims are spread every day by our public figures and media. Intentional or not, they have the power to shape the choices we make. We all deserve better than that.
That’s why we’re fighting to keep this election more honest and accountable. And we can’t do it without you. In a fast-paced campaign, our supporters mean we can hold all candidates to the same three principles: get your facts right, back them up with evidence, and correct your mistakes.
Just a small monthly donation keeps us scrutinising the most harmful false claims around the clock, and challenging the people who make them.
If you, like us, don’t want your vote to be influenced by bad information, can you help out?