A post on Facebook shows a screenshot of a tweet from Health Secretary Sajid Javid, saying “Looking forward to opening one of new 48 [sic] hospitals later today.”
The accompanying text on Facebook says: “More lies from the Conservative Party. This is a new cancer centre that was in the pipeline years before Mr Johnson made his 2019 pledge. It’s a building at an existing hospital in Carlisle paid for [by] private foreign investment & rented to the NHS for fifty years at a high cost. One new “hospital” is an entrance hall extension to the existing building.”
Mr Javid’s tweet has also been criticised by Labour MPs including shadow health secretary Jonathan Ashworth, deputy leader Angela Rayner and Dawn Butler.
It’s true that Sajid Javid officially opened a cancer care centre in Carlisle, Cumbria on 19 August. However, whether you’d call this a new hospital depends on your definition of those two words.
The Northern Centre for Cancer Care, North Cumbria was built on the former site of the tower block building at the Cumberland Infirmary. The Cumberland Infirmary in its current form was opened in 2000 and built under private finance initiative, or PFI.
PFI is a way of funding large public projects like hospitals, where private financiers pay upfront and are then paid back over many years. This seems to be what the post is referencing when it says the hospital is being “rented” to the NHS.
Although the Facebook post refers to foreign investment, the cancer centre was paid for in a joint venture by two British multinationals: AMEC and Interserve.
Honesty in public debate matters
You can help us take action – and get our regular free email
What is a new hospital?
When challenged on Mr Javid’s claim, the Department for Health and Social Care (DHSC) told ITV: “There are numerous hospitals which specialise in one area of care or that are co-located—they are nonetheless hospitals.
“We have always been clear that the scale and size of each new hospital will vary depending on what is required for each local area.
“In some cases, that will be whole new hospitals on a new site, and in other cases, a new hospital on an existing site with dedicated facilities for particular conditions, such as cancer.”
Earlier this year the DHSC put out invites for NHS trusts to express an interest in being involved in “a further 8 new hospitals to deliver on our commitment to fund and build a total of 40 new hospitals by 2030”. The DHSC defined a new hospital as one of three things:
- a whole new hospital site on a new site or current NHS land (either a single service or consolidation of services on a new site),
- a major new clinical building on an existing site or a new wing of an existing hospital (provided it contains a whole clinical service, such as maternity or children’s services),
- a major refurbishment and alteration of all but the building frame or main structure, delivering a significant extension to useful life which includes major or visible changes to the external structure.
Although the government press release refers to the new Carlisle building as a “cancer hospital”, the NHS trust’s own website refers to it as a “cancer centre”.
The new building is more than an entrance hall
The new cancer centre contains:
- two linear accelerator radiotherapy machines
- a chemotherapy day unit with 15 treatment chairs and three single treatment rooms
- a CT scanner suite
- consultation, examination rooms and a small café area
- multipurpose rooms for complementary therapies and patient support.
According to the DHSC, the centre “is a partnership between North Cumbria Integrated Care NHS Foundation Trust and the Newcastle upon Tyne Hospitals NHS Foundation Trust” but once complete, “the service will be run by Newcastle Hospitals as part of the Northern Centre for Cancer Care.”
Newcastle Hospitals Trust runs healthcare from a number of different sites, including this new centre. The rest of Cumbria Infirmary is run by the North Cumbria Integrated Care NHS Foundation Trust.
The centre has been in the works since before the election
It’s true that the cancer centre was planned before Boris Johnson’s October 2019 election pledge to “build 40 new hospitals” (a pledge which later became 48 new hospitals).
The architect that built the new cancer centre, P+HS published a picture on its website of the building site in Carlisle showing that the 1960s tower block had “been completely flattened, making way for a new £35m oncology centre”. This was published on 17 May 2019.