This letter claiming to be from a doctor in Surrey is full of errors
23 July 2020
What was claimed
A letter from a consultant at a hospital in Surrey claims that hospitals are empty and that there is no pandemic.
There are numerous inconsistencies in the letter which suggest it is not from someone working at a hospital in Surrey.
A lettershared widely on social media, claiming to be from a doctor based at a Surrey hospital, makes numerous claims about the Covid-19 pandemic, including that doctors are not wearing masks, hospitals are empty, and that there is “no pandemic”.
The letter appeared to have been first shared by a Twitter account set up in May. Tweets linking to an account on the file sharing site Dropbox, which contains the letter and genuine Covid-19 death certificate guidance have since been deleted by that Twitter user.
We’ve addressed some of the key claims in the letter below, as well as issues medical professionals have with the letter in general.
Hospital attendance is down in Surrey, but not by 95%
The letter’s general claim that patient numbers were down 95% in the period March to June is incorrect, as is suggesting hospital attendance figures are “almost impossible to get hold of”. These figures are published on the NHS England website.
It’s true that hospital attendance was down in hospitals in Surrey, as it was across the country, but the drop is far less than claimed. Comparing A&E attendance for April to June this year to the same period in 2019 across the five major hospital trusts that cover Surrey (the Surrey and Sussex Healthcare NHS Trust, the Royal Surrey County Hospital Trust, Ashford and St Peter’s Trust, Epsom and St Helier Trust and Frimley Health Trust), attendances were down an average of 37%, with the highest attendance drop of 44% being seen in Epsom.
Outpatient data for June 2020 wasn’t available at time of writing. However, comparing data for April and May of this year to the same period in 2019, first outpatient attendances at the five trusts were down by 46%. While these figures show a reduction, this does not show the 95% drop claimed in the letter.
The letter also claims that “In my opinion, and that of many of my colleagues, there has been no Covid Pandemic, certainly not in the Surrey region”. Figures from NHS England show that across the five trusts, there were over 1,100 deaths in hospitals of patients who had previously tested positive for Covid-19.
The letter has other credibility issues
Full Fact asked Dr Julia Patterson of campaign group Every Doctor what she thought of the letter. She said that doctors in its forum had said that the letter doesn’t feel or read like it was written by someone in the medical profession. Dr Patterson says that despite managing a forum of thousands of doctors, this is the first time she has seen these claims.
On the claim that “The trust has been running empty ambulances during lockdown”, doctors in the Every Doctor forum pointed out that ambulances are operated by trusts separate to hospitals.
The letter’s approach to describing a pandemic in local terms is not one that would be taken by a real medical professional according to Dr Patterson. Pandemics are countrywide or global.
The NHS told Reuters, in a statement supported by both the Surrey and Sussex Healthcare NHS Trust and the South East Coast Ambulance Service NHS Foundation Trust, that “The content and claims made within this social media post are not recognised by the local NHS”.
The genuine death certificate guidance linked to in the Dropbox accompanying this letter does not mention anywhere that medical professionals should list Covid-19 as a cause of death, regardless of the actual cause, as the letter claims.
This article is part of our work fact checking potentially false pictures, videos and stories on Facebook. You can read more about this—and find out how to report Facebook content—here.
For the purposes of that scheme, we’ve rated this claim as false
because claims in the post are wrong and evidence points to the fact that this was not written by an A&E doctor in Surrey.
We can’t sugar coat how difficult this year has been for good information.
News this year has fractured communities, and caused confusion and panic for many of us. No one can control what will happen next. But you can support a debate based on fair, accurate and transparent information.
As independent, impartial fact checkers, we rely on individuals like you to ensure the most dangerously false inaccuracies can be called out and challenged.
Could you chip in to support an accurate and fair debate today?